rss
Qual Saf Health Care 11:315-319 doi:10.1136/qhc.11.4.315

Comparison of patients’ and general practitioners’ evaluations of general practice care

Table 3

Patients’ and GPs’ evaluations of care and GPs’ perceptions of patients’ evaluations. Rank orders based on valid percentages evaluating positively as 4 or 5 on a 5 point Likert scale

Patients’ evaluations (n=1772) GPs’ evaluations (n=315) GPs’ perceptions of patients’ evaluations (n=315)
What is your opinion of the GP and/or general practice over the last 12 months with respect to . . .* Rank no (%) Absolute no Rank no (%) Absolute no Rank no (%) Absolute no
*Stem in the questionnaire for GPs: “What is your own opinion of yourself and/or your general practice over the last 12 months with respect to . . .” and “What is your perception of the opinion of your patients of you and/or your general practice over the last 12 months with respect to . . .”. The word “you” was replaced by “patients” in all 23 items for general practitioners, e.g. “making patients feel they had time during consultations”, so the words “him or her”, “s/he”, “his or her” were replaced by “you” or “your”.
**Dimensions of general practice care: I=doctor-patient relationship (6 items); II=information and support (4 items); III=medical-–technical care (5 items); IV=organisation of services (8 items).
Keeping your records and data confidential? (I)** 1 (94.6) 1440 2 (88.9) 279 1 (85.8) 266
Listening to you? (I) 2 (88.5) 1546 4 (78.1) 246 7 (60.3) 190
Making you feel you had time during consultations? (I) 3 (87.8) 1540 5 (74.0) 223 12 (52.5) 165
Providing quick services for urgent health problems? (IV) 4 (85.2) 1137 1 (93.9) 295 2 (80.6) 253
Helpfulness of the staff (other than the doctor)? (IV) 5 (83.8) 1329 3 (79.2) 248 4 (64.4) 201
Explaining the purpose of tests and treatments? (II) 6 (83.3) 1331 11 (66.6) 209 11 (53.0) 166
Telling you what you wanted to know about your symptoms and/or illness? (II) 7 (82.7) 1399 10 (67.2) 211 13 (50.3) 158
Making it easy for you to tell him or her about your problems? (I) 8 (82.5) 1399 13 (63.8) 201 16 (46.8) 147
Physical examination of you? (III) 9 (82.4) 1328 6 (73.9) 232 3 (65.8) 206
Interest in your personal situation? (I) 10 (82.0) 1409 8 (70.8) 223 8 (56.5) 178
Thoroughness? (III) 11 (81.2) 1361 9 (68.4) 214 6 (61.2) 191
Involving you in decisions about your medical care? (I) 12 (81.0) 1323 7 (72.7) 229 5 (61.3) 193
Helping you to understand the importance of following his or her advice? (II) 13 (79.7) 1141 21 (47.9) 150 18 (36.5) 113
Helping you to feel well so that you can perform your normal daily activities? (III) 14 (78.7) 1172 19 (53.8) 161 17 (37.9) 113
Getting an appointment to suit you? (IV) 15 (78.1) 1335 14 (60.8) 191 20 (34.4) 108
Knowing what s/he had done or told you during contacts? (IV) 16 (76.2) 1135 20 (52.7) 164 10 (54.4) 168
Offering you services for preventing diseases (eg screening, health checks, immunisations)? (III) 17 (76.1) 953 16 (59.2) 184 9 (54.9) 168
Helping you deal with emotional problems related to your health status? (II) 18 (75.5) 873 17 (57.6) 181 15 (47.3) 148
Quick relief of your symptoms? (III) 19 (74.8) 1239 22 (41.4) 126 23 (24.8) 75
Preparing you for what to expect from specialist or hospital care? (IV) 20 (74.7) 818 23 (40.4) 127 21 (31.2) 97
Being able to speak to the GP on the telephone? (IV) 21 (71.9) 1051 12 (65.3) 205 19 (34.7) 109
Getting through to the practice on the phone? (IV) 22 (71.3) 1247 18 (55.1) 173 22 (28.3) 89
Waiting time in the waiting room? (IV) 23 (61.2) 1066 15 (60.5) 190 14 (48.6) 152

This Article

Free sample

This recent issue is free to all users to allow everyone the opportunity to see the full scope and typical content of BMJ Quality & Safety.
View free sample issue >>

Don't forget to sign up for content alerts so you keep up to date with all the articles as they are published.