Article Text

PDF
Assessing distractors and teamwork during surgery: developing an event-based method for direct observation
  1. Julia C Seelandt1,
  2. Franziska Tschan1,
  3. Sandra Keller1,
  4. Guido Beldi3,
  5. Nadja Jenni1,
  6. Anita Kurmann3,
  7. Daniel Candinas3,
  8. Norbert K Semmer2
  1. 1University of Neuchâtel, Institute for Work and Organizational Psychology, Neuchâtel, Switzerland
  2. 2University of Bern, Institute for Psychology, Bern, Switzerland
  3. 3Department of Visceral Surgery and Medicine, University Hospital of Bern, Bern, Switzerland
  1. Correspondence to Professor Franziska Tschan, University of Neuchâtel, Rue Emile Argand 11, Neuchâtel 2000, Switzerland; Franziska.tschan{at}unine.ch

Abstract

Objective To develop a behavioural observation method to simultaneously assess distractors and communication/teamwork during surgical procedures through direct, on-site observations; to establish the reliability of the method for long (>3 h) procedures.

Methods Observational categories for an event-based coding system were developed based on expert interviews, observations and a literature review. Using Cohen's κ and the intraclass correlation coefficient, interobserver agreement was assessed for 29 procedures. Agreement was calculated for the entire surgery, and for the 1st hour. In addition, interobserver agreement was assessed between two tired observers and between a tired and a non-tired observer after 3 h of surgery.

Results The observational system has five codes for distractors (door openings, noise distractors, technical distractors, side conversations and interruptions), eight codes for communication/teamwork (case-relevant communication, teaching, leadership, problem solving, case-irrelevant communication, laughter, tension and communication with external visitors) and five contextual codes (incision, last stitch, personnel changes in the sterile team, location changes around the table and incidents). Based on 5-min intervals, Cohen's κ was good to excellent for distractors (0.74–0.98) and for communication/teamwork (0.70–1). Based on frequency counts, intraclass correlation coefficient was excellent for distractors (0.86–0.99) and good to excellent for communication/teamwork (0.45–0.99). After 3 h of surgery, Cohen's κ was 0.78–0.93 for distractors, and 0.79–1 for communication/teamwork.

Discussion The observational method developed allows a single observer to simultaneously assess distractors and communication/teamwork. Even for long procedures, high interobserver agreement can be achieved. Data collected with this method allow for investigating separate or combined effects of distractions and communication/teamwork on surgical performance and patient outcomes.

  • Human Factors
  • Teamwork
  • Communication
  • Surgery

Statistics from Altmetric.com

Request permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.