Original articleRisk of falls for hospitalized patients: A predictive model based on routinely available data
Introduction
Many hospitals routinely report inpatient falls. As a matter of fact, falls are the most frequently noted incidents 1, 2. Quality assurance programs insist upon the importance of monitoring adverse events and often use fall rates as an indicator of nursing outcome 3, 4, 5. Wide variations in fall rates have been reported among institutions for the elderly (0.2–3.6 per bed per year) [6]. Studies in acute-care hospitals are less numerous, but also show notable variations: 2–15% of inpatients experience at least one fall 1, 7, 8, 9, 10, the range of published incidence rates of falls is wide (0.3–19 for 1000 patient-days) 1, 7, 8, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15. Comparing fall rates among various institutions may be helpful but raises concerns. The lack of an accurate definition of the occurrence indicator compromises data comparability 16, 17. The unit of measurement is often the number of events per patient-days but multiple falls by the same individuals are variably reported, and falls that do not result in visible injuries are sometimes not reported at all. What is more important is that, to clarify the issue of nursing care quality, factors outside the direct influence of hospital policy should be controlled for. Interpreting an outcome must therefore account for variations linked to case mix. Although falls are a traditional target of risk management, comparative data are too scant to set a benchmark determining an acceptable level of falls [18].
Controlling for patient risk is required to evaluate quality differences between care settings. Most research to date has focused on elderly persons living in the community or in nursing homes. A number of researchers have investigated symptoms that may contribute to a fall in these environments: gait and balance disorders 13, 19, 20, 21, dizziness or vertigo 21, 22, visual deficit [23], incontinence [24], cognitive impairment and sedation 6, 19, 24, 25. Selected risk factors have been used to derive relatively simple assessment tools identifying patients liable to be targeted for preventive strategies 13, 24, 26. Because these data have to be extracted from medical or nursing records, they are not readily available for comparison across care units or hospitals. Furthermore, many of those variables escape detection because they are not regularly recorded in medical records [25]. It has been shown that in acute-care settings a few variables could identify patients prone to falls: falls during hospitalization are more common in confused patients and those with greater comorbidity [25]. Several diseases have been shown to increase the risk of fall such as Alzheimer's disease [27], Parkinson's disease [28] and stroke [10]. These findings suggest that risk measures relying only on routinely collected data could perform quite well for hospitalized patients and favorably compare with methods requiring additional record abstracting.
A further concern is the necessity to adopt a probabilistic approach, due to the fact that it is usually difficult to determine whether a fall might have been avoided on a case-by-case basis. Data about the proportion of potentially avoidable falls are scarce; a systematic medical records review of adverse events in hospitalized patients judged that over half of 200 falls with injuries resulted from substandard care [29]. Few falls can be clearly prevented, for instance by suppressing a form of medication or an environmental hazard. Some are probably unavoidable, such as in a unit trying to improve the independent living skills of its patients [30]. Most patients fall because factors related to patients and to environmental hazards interact. In fact, only multifactorial interventions targeting both intrinsic and environmental risk factors have been shown to significantly reduce the number of falls in high-risk populations 31, 32, 33.
The objectives of the study were: (1) to measure the incidence of falls and to describe the circumstances under which they occur, and (2) to use routinely collected information to develop a prediction model, making it possible to compare observed rates accounting for the identifiable patients' risks.
Hospital characteristics, such as the type of care unit and the patient:nurse ratio, were intentionally not taken into account in order to use only case mix variables clearly beyond the hospital's control.
Section snippets
Methods
The Centre Hospitalier Universitaire Vaudois (CHUV) offers an appropriate setting to observe falls, document their circumstances and measure potential risk factors. It generates intense activity (more than 200,000 hospitalization days per annum) for a comprehensive panel of patients—all surgical and medical services provided to patients of all ages with all specialized areas of medicine represented except ophthalmology and psychiatry. Thus, the CHUV presents a large spectrum of predictive
Description of falls
Six hundred thirty-four falls were reported during 236,307 hospitalization days, corresponding to a global rate of 2.7 falls per 1000 days. The proportion of inpatients falling was 1.8% (488/26,643). The incidence rate was 2.2 first falls per 1000 days. Twenty percent of patients with a first fall relapsed (100/488) during the follow-up period. The incidence rate of a second fall by patients who had fallen previously was 12.7 per 1000 days (100/7893). The incidence rate of a subsequent fall
Comments
The multivariate model offers good predictive performance. Poisson modeling is adequate and data do not present over-dispersion. The range of predicted rates is large, varying from a low of 0.32 per 1000 days to 9.87 in the high- risk group. The age variable is the most significant factor, which comes as no surprise from a medical point of view. The fact that morbidity predisposition and length of stay show similar contributions suggests that AP-DRGs do not sufficiently account for the severity
References (51)
- et al.
A prospective study to identify the fall prone patient
Soc Sci Med
(1989) - et al.
Calculating fall ratesmethodological concerns
Qual Rev Bull
(1988) - et al.
Methodologic issues in the study of frequent and recurrent health problemsfalls in the elderly
Ann Epidemiol
(1990) - et al.
Setting realistic goals for quality assurance monitoringpatient falls versus patients days
Qual Rev Bull
(1987) - et al.
Gait and balance in the elderlytwo functional capacities that link sensory and motor ability to falls
Clin Geriatr Med
(1985) - et al.
Hospital fallsdevelopment of a predictive model for clinical practice
Appl Nurs Res
(1995) - et al.
Serious falls in hospitalized patientscorrelates and resource utilization
Am J Med
(1995) - et al.
Fall risk index for elderly patients based on number of chronic disabilities
Am J Med
(1986) - et al.
A multifactorial approach to reducing injurious falls
Clin Geriatr Med
(1996) - et al.
Falls in a psychiatric unit
Appl Nurs Res
(1998)
Issues for comparability of DRG statistics in Europeresults from EURODRG
Health Policy
Hospital fallsa persistent problem
Am J Public Health
Patient accidents in hospitalincidence, documentation and significance
Br J Clin Pract
Developing a nursing quality assurance programassessment and planning
Patients fallsan outcome indicator
J Nurs Care Qual
Nursing quality indicatorsdefinitions and indications
Falls in the nursing home
Ann Intern Med
Evolution of compliance within a fall prevention program
J Nurs Care Qual
The quality improvement system in the hospitals of Padua (Italy)
Qual Assurance Health Care
A retrospective cohort study of falls in a psychiatric inpatient setting
Hosp Community Psychiatry
Risk factors for falls of hospitalized stroke patients
Stroke
Incidence of falls in three different types of geriatric carea Swedish prospective study
Scand J Soc Med
A retrospective analysis of patient falls
Can J Public Health
Falls on a neurorehabilitation unitreassessment of a prevention program
J Am Paraplegia Soc
Falls by hospitalized elderly patientscauses, prevention
Geriatrics
Cited by (159)
Biomechanical investigation of optimal bed height for egressing and ingressing hospital beds
2023, Human Factors in HealthcareHigh prevalence of outpatient falls following elective shoulder arthroplasty
2020, Journal of Shoulder and Elbow SurgeryIncidence, correlates and outcomes associated with falls in the intensive care unit: a retrospective cohort study
2017, Critical Care and ResuscitationFalls and fractures in the acute care setting: A retrospective cohort study
2023, Australasian Journal on AgeingClinical Characteristics and Outcomes of Inpatient Falls During Inpatient Rehabilitation: A Case-Control Study
2023, American Journal of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation