Table 3

Comparison of the intention-to-treat decisions with the standard per profession: appropriate versus undertreatment and overtreatment

UndertreatmentAppropriateOvertreatment
Values are percentages of cases scored with numbers in parentheses.
Overall χ2=72; df=6.
*Significantly different from mean rate of concordnace for all professions together (p<0.01).
General practitioners22 (275)66 (827)12 (144)
Psychiatrists13 (198)*73 (1094)*14 (214)*
Psychotherapists25 (429)*67 (1133)7 (125)*
Clinical psychologists21 (271)71 (917)8 (102)*
All professions21 (1173)69 (3971)10 (585)