Table 2

Quality assessment of studies

Quality criteriaCategoriesNumber of studies (% of relevant studies)
Type of study (n=90)Simple descriptive34 (37)
Pre-feedback data from audit studies46 (50)
Control data from experimental studies12 (13)
Sampling of practices (n=90)Self-selected60 (67)
Random16 (18)
All5 (6)
Not stated9 (9)
Number of practices (n=90)118 (20)
2–615 (17)
7+52 (58)
Not stated5 (5)
Number of patients (n=89)<506 (7)
50–10010 (11)
101–50029 (32)
>50040 (46)
Not stated4 (4)
Not applicable1
Response rate of Gps (n=57)<25%3 (5)
25–50%7 (12)
51–75%11 (19)
76–100%16 (27)
Not stated22 (37)
Not applicable33