Regular ArticleHow People Respond to Contingent Valuation Questions: A Verbal Protocol Analysis of Willingness to Pay for an Environmental Regulation
Abstract
This paper investigates what a respondent is thinking when answering a willingness-to-pay question in a contingent valuation, using a "think aloud" technique from psychology called verbal protocol analysis. The willingness-to-pay responses we observed seem to be constructed from a variety of considerations, including an obligation to pay a fair share of the cost of the solution and signaling concern for a larger set of environmental issues. The finding that respondents seem to construct their values at the time they are asked, rather than reporting a more well-defined value, is seen as consistent with over two decades of research on the psychology of decision making. Potential uses of verbal protocols in contingent valuation studies are also discussed.
References (0)
Cited by (343)
Valuing externalities of outdoor advertising in an urban setting – the case of Warsaw
2022, Journal of Urban EconomicsOutdoor advertising (OA) produces externalities, such as access to information and visual pollution, that have to be considered in cityscape planning. We propose a theoretical model of demand for OA that considers positive and negative externalities, as well as consumers income and advertising space they can rent. We then present the results of a stated preference study aimed at estimating the value that people attach to the reductions of OA in Warsaw, the capital of Poland. We considered two types of OA mediums: free-standing ads and on-building ads, alongside five levels of advertising reduction. We find that inhabitants of Warsaw prefer regulating and limiting the amount of OA and we quantify their willingness to pay for such a policy. In total, the people of Warsaw were willing to pay from 1.7 to 4.1 million EUR per year for limiting the number of free-standing ads and 5.5–9.3 million EUR per year for limiting of advertising on buildings, depending on the scope of reductions. The results are used for validating the theoretical model. They also serve as input for a benefit-cost analysis of optimal regulation and provide a basis for designing market-based instruments (e.g., Pigouvian tax) to adjust the amount of advertising to socially optimal level. Overall, our study demonstrates how stated preference methods can be used for informing urban landscape policies and adds to the ongoing debate surrounding OA.
Instability in mixed logit demand models
2022, Journal of Choice ModellingWhen a mixed logit demand model is used to estimate market-clearing prices, the high influence of the left tail of the random price coefficient can lead to numerical and statistical instability. I show this is an issue with any mixing distribution whose price coefficient is not bounded away from zero. I give conditions under which market equilibrium prices implied by mixed logit models exist, and show they are satisfied for lognormal mixing and some cases of truncated normal mixing. However, even when market equilibria exist, these models can be unstable and produce statistically unreliable and economically implausible conclusions.
Can respondent uncertainty be ignored when exploring heterogeneity in public preferences for air pollution treatment policies? Comparative results from choice experiment analysis
2022, Science of the Total EnvironmentBased on choice experiment (CE), evaluating the public's heterogeneous preferences and willingness to pay (WTP) for air pollution treatment policies can provide useful social views for the reasonable formulation of treatment schemes. However, the application of CE contains an implicit assumption that respondents understand their real preferences and can make choices with complete certainty. In reality, for a variety of reasons, not all respondents are absolutely certain about their responses, this assumption distinctly is hard to be consistent with reality. To explore the impact of respondent uncertainty on the public's WTP and heterogeneous preferences for air pollution treatment policies, this study introduces the critical point and exponential weighting methods to deal with this uncertainty in the context of CE and conducts comparative analysis based on the random parameters logit (RPL) and latent classes models (LCM). The results show that, ignoring uncertainty leads to distortions in the public's WTP and preference characteristics. In the RPL models, on average, the WTP for attributes is overstated by 32.10%. Our results also reveal that, whether to consider uncertainty does not affect the ranking of the implicit prices of these attributes. After incorporating uncertainty into the analysis, respondents were divided into two potential groups with different preferences, namely the environment-focused group (79.44%) and the price-focused group (20.56%), which is quite distinct from research results of ignoring the uncertainty. Contribution of this study is not only to provide theoretical insights for exploring the effects of uncertainty on public preferences based on CE, but also to provide valuable guidance for policy makers to formulate more accurate and effective treatment measures.
On-site decision-making in smartphone-mediated contexts
2022, Tourism ManagementThe smartphone has become an indispensable travel companion for contemporary tourists. However, how smartphone use during the trip changes the travel context and related travel decision-making is still unclear. By tracing the in-situ decision-making processes in a real-world setting, this empirical study develops a deep understanding of the role of smartphones in shaping the physical and social contexts within which on-site decisions are made. The findings suggest that smartphones create a complex phygital-social context that triggers and supports the development of new travel plans, re-examination of pre-trip plans, and cancellation of pre-trip plans. Interactions with the smartphone-mediated context facilitate efficient decision-making and enable experience optimization. This study provides implications for decision-making theory in tourism and offers practical implications for destination marketing and management.
Consumers’ willingness to pay for plants protected by beneficial insects – Evidence from two stated-choice experiments with different subject pools
2021, Food PolicyWe investigate consumers’ willingness to pay for edible and non-edible plants protected by beneficial insects and those protected by pesticides, respectively, as well as the influence of message framing on willingness to pay. We use basil, heather, and orchids as experimental objects in two stated-choice experiments (one lab-in-the-field experiment and one online experiment) conducted in Germany. In both experiments, we find strong evidence that consumers prefer plants protected by beneficial insects. Moreover, we find that message framing affects consumers’ willingness to pay, where gain framing produces greater overall willingness to pay. To check for the robustness of our results, we implemented instruments to mitigate concerns for social desirability and hypothetical bias, finding that our results are robust in terms of our key findings. This is the first comprehensive experimental study specifically on consumer’s willingness to pay for plants protected by beneficial insects. Our findings are valuable for practitioners, as the use of beneficial insects in greenhouse production is already rather common. Following our results, this information could be successfully used for marketing purposes.
Why is the grass greener on the other side? Decision modes and location choice by wind energy investors
2019, Journal of Business ResearchThis study examines the role of decision modes, defined as the qualitatively different manners in which choices are made, in location choices, which is a critical investment decision type. While the research has primarily emphasised critical antecedents of location choices, namely context-level, task-level or individual-level factors, we uncover the critical role of the decision process by investigating decision-making modes. Based on a verbal protocol study in a choice experiment of 12 location choices for wind energy projects, we uncover systematic differences in the utilised decision modes and their interactions. We showcase that one decision mode type, recognition mode, leads to an asymmetric evaluation of the project location options and is triggered by institutionalised expectations and beliefs. With these findings, we contribute to the literatures concerned with the psychology of location choices and investment decision-making generally.