EMS/Original contribution
The emergent problem of ambulance misuse

https://doi.org/10.1016/S0196-0644(05)81841-4Get rights and content

Study objective:

The primary objective was to determine whether rates of ambulance misuse varied systematically by type of health insurance. The secondary objective was to determine whether the level of service provided in the ambulance varied by ambulance company ownership.

Design:

Survey.

Setting:

A 175-bed community hospital in central Connecticut.

Participants:

One hundred forty-five records were selected randomly for study from the records of the 488 patients presenting to the hospital emergency department within a 45-day period.

Outcome measures:

The urgency of presenting complaint and the use of life support measures within the ambulance were obtained from each ambulance run form. Type of health insurance, clinical data, and disposition were obtained from ED records. Ambulance use was deemed unnecessary if the patient's presenting complaint was nonurgent, the patient was ambulatory, and the patient was not ultimately hospitalized. Advanced life support measures were deemed unnecessary if they were applied to patients with nonurgent complaints.

Results:

Patients with private insurance made appropriate use of ambulances in 77.8% of cases, patients with Medicare did so in 65.8% of cases, and patients with Medicaid did so in 14.7% of cases. These results were statistically significant at P < .001. Among patients with Medicare, ambulance misuse was more common among nursing home residents. Approximately 20% of the observed misuse was related to alcohol intoxication. Although it did not reach statistical significance, we noted a higher frequency of inappropriate use of advanced life support measures in patients brought to the ED by a private ambulance service than for those brought by a municipal service.

Conclusion:

Ambulance misuse is common in the studied community and may be related to the broader problem of the provision of care to the poor or otherwise underserved. Our results raise several interesting questions for further research.

References (19)

There are more references available in the full text version of this article.

Cited by (80)

  • Objective evaluation study on the shortest time interval from fire department departure to hospital arrival in emergency medical services using a global positioning system ― potential for time savings during ambulance running

    2021, IATSS Research
    Citation Excerpt :

    The number of emergency vehicles dispatched in Japan in 2017 was 6,342,147 (up 132,183 or 2.1% from the previous year) and has been increasing consistently since 2004. As background, this shows the use of meaningless emergency medical services (EMS) and an increase in the elderly population [1,2]. As a result, the time interval from when a call is received to when a patient arrives at a hospital has extended annually due to the limited operation of ambulances.

  • Emergency department visits in patients with low acuity conditions: Factors associated with resource utilization

    2018, American Journal of Emergency Medicine
    Citation Excerpt :

    Many studies use these terms [6,24,29-31], nonetheless, there is not a universally accepted definition of “misuse” or “inappropriate use [32,34].” Previous studies support that the majority of patients who are transported by EMS have emergent complaints [24-26,30,31,33,35]. However, the use of EMS “simply as a convenient means of transportation to the ED” clearly reflects “a misunderstanding of the purpose…or disregard for the social cost of the service” [7].

  • Older people's use of pre-hospital emergency medical services in Izmir, Turkey

    2010, Archives of Gerontology and Geriatrics
    Citation Excerpt :

    It was found in a study conducted in Sweden that cardiovascular illnesses were the leading preclinical conditions (Hjalte et al., 2007). The problem of inappropriate ambulance use among the elderly has been reported worldwide, which accounts for 40–50% of total utilization of ambulance services in some developed countries (Brown and Sindelar, 1992). There were 15,371 ambulance calls in Yokohama Fire Bureau in Japan in 2004, however, approximately 60% of the transported subjects were non-urgent, to represent unnecessary ambulance use (Kawakami et al., 2007).

View all citing articles on Scopus
View full text