Article Text

Download PDFPDF

039 Guideline Developers’ Self-Perceptions of Adherence to and Intentions to Adhere to the IOM Standards
  1. J Jue1,
  2. L Haskell1,
  3. S Cunningham1,
  4. M Nix2,
  5. V Coates1
  1. 1ECRI Institute, Plymouth Meeting, USA
  2. 2Agency for Healthcare Quality and Research, Rockville, USA


Background The 2011 IOM report called for more rigorous and transparent development of guidelines. Compliance with the IOM Standards may be challenging for developers. Developer perception of their current adherence to the Standards gives insight into their understanding of them and the likelihood of adhering to them in the future.

Objectives (1) Assess developers’ self-perceptions of adherence to the IOM standards (2) Assess developers’ intentions to adhere to the IOM standards.

Methods This AHRQ funded work used a mixed-methods approach. We performed semi-structured telephone interviews and surveys to query developers about impressions of and intentions to implement the IOM standards in their CPGs. We also performed our own assessments of guidelines and compared them with developer self-ratings.

Results Of 14 developers, 43% utilised a systematic review to underpin their guidelines, and 57% felt they would in the future. Funding sources were not disclosed by 46% of the developers. While 80% utilised an evidence rating scheme, fewer rated the recommendations. Notable differences between developer self-ratings and researcher assessments of adherence occurred in several areas.

Discussion While some developers intend to improve processes to meet the Standards, others acknowledged they will not. Yet still others felt they already met the standards, but our assessment suggested a different estimation, revealing varying understanding among developers of the Standards.

Implications for Guideline Developers/Users The IOM standards will help identify rigorous and transparent evidence-based guidelines, but will pose implementation challenges. Education of developers on the Standards and expectations around them will be critical.

Statistics from

Request Permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.