Intervention suggestions
Intervention idea | Suggested in article authored by |
INCREASE MEDICAL KNOWLEDGE AND EXPERIENCE | |
General | |
Increase expertise and experience | Kassirer et al47; Gigerenzer48; Elstein49; Klein50 51; Berner and Graber1; Bazerman and Moore52; Norman53 |
Training | |
Routinely test competency in diagnostic accuracy; provide training to increase competency | Smith-Bindman et al54; Singh et al55 |
Continuing education | Bowen56; Davis et al57 |
Focused training on specific content area | Freidlander and Phillips58; Gentner59; Hershberger et al60; Parmley61 |
Improve learning skills, per se | Hogarth62 |
Simulation | |
Develop simulation exercises to expose clinicians to a greater number and variety of case presentations | Bond et al63 |
Feedback and calibration | |
Provide intensive, detailed, specific feedback | Smith-Bindman et al54; Schiff64; Jamtvedt et al65; Papa et al66; Stone and Opel67; Alpert and Hillman68; Arkes69; Humble et al70; Pulford and Colman71; Subbotin72 |
Learn from errors | Fischer et al73; Hogarth62; Eva74 |
IMPROVE INTUITIVE AND DELIBERATE PROCESSES IN DECISION-MAKING | |
General | |
Improve general training on clinical reasoning & the dual process model | Berner and Graber1; Kassirer et al47; Elstein49; Eva74 75; Croskerry76–78; Norman53; Wolpaw et al23 |
Improve system 1 processing | |
Improve training on intuitive processing and its shortcomings | Berner and Graber1; Croskerry76–78; Wedding and Faust79 Groves et al80; Pines81; Moulton et al,82 Trowbridge83; Kuhn84 |
Debias your own intuitive decisions | Croskerry 76–78; Norman53; Fischhoff85; Milkman86 Larrick87; Gentner et al59; Koriat et al88; Renner and Renner89; Estrada et al90 Scott91; Slovic and Fischoff92 Arkes et al69 154; Lichtenstein et al93 |
Improve metacognition, nurture intuition and use of reflective practice | Schon94; Greenhalgh95; Mamede et al96; Singh et al97; Brawn98; Gregory99; Noddings and Shore100; Quirk101; Klein51; Hogarth62; Hamm and Zubialde102; Moulton et al82; Trowbridge83; Croskerry76–78 103 |
Use a checklist or related tools | Leonidas104; Gawande105; Trowbridge83; Ely et al106 |
Consider alternatives; consider the opposite; use prospective hindsight; think like an outsider | Taleb107; Wedding and Faust79; Sackett et al158; Brannick et al108; Milkman et al86; Arkes109; Croskerry78; Schwenk110; Baron111; Mitchell et al112; Bazerman and Moore86; Mussweiler113; Lord et al114; Arzy et al115; Gorman and Gorman116; Hirt and Markman117; Mumma and Steven118; Singh97 |
Improve system 2 processing | |
Teach principles of clinical reasoning; use evidence-based medicine and normative decision-making | Wedding and Faust79; Strauss et al119; Sox120; Dobbie et al121; Khan and Coomarasamy122; Croskerry123; Pines81; Ullman124; Pauker and Kassirer125; Kassirer126; Brannick et al108 |
Provide training on the typical pitfalls of specific clinical conditions & situations | Groves et al80; Croskerry78; Pines81 |
GET HELP FROM OTHER PEOPLE AND/OR DECISION SUPPORT TOOLS | |
Second opinions | |
Use specialist consultants & second opinions; improve team-based decisions, for example, by having a devil's advocate | Elstein49; Christensen et al34; Tatarka127 |
Second readings in pathology | Ullman124; Raab128 |
Groups and librarians | |
Get help from groups or librarians | Zipperer and Sykes129; Albert130; Zipperer131 |
Actuarial decisions | |
Use of guidelines, clinical algorithms, linear models and mnemonics to reduce reliance on memory | Elstein49; Croskerry78; Berner and Graber1; Tatarka127; Milkman et al86; Wedding and Faust79; Wedding132; Fischhoff85 |
Focused decision support | |
Decision support tool on a specific condition | Hunt et al133; Klassen et al134; Garg et al135; Cannon and Allen136 |
Improve data display through graphics | Radecki and Medow137; Reyna et al138; Bhandari et al139; Cook and Smallman140 |
Embedded decision support tools; Infobuttons | Kawamoto and Loback141 |
General decision support | |
Improve medical records | Hamm and Zubialde102; Schiff and Bates142 |