Table 1

Frequencies (%) and types of root causes of diagnosis-related incidents at emergency departments that resulted in malpractice claims in 2001 and 2002

Description*n (%)
Technical failures
 T-ExTechnical failures beyond the control and responsibility of the investigating organisation0 (0)
 TDInadequate design of equipment, software or materials0 (0)
 TCCorrect design of equipment that were not constructed properly0 (0)
 TMMaterial defects0 (0)
Organisational failures
 O-EXOrganisation failures beyond the control and responsibility of the investigating organisation2 (1.8)
 OKFailures resulting form inadequate measures taken to ensure that situational or site-specific knowledge or information is transferred to all new or inexperienced staff0 (0)
 OPThe quality and availability of the protocols, that is they are complicated, inaccurate, unrealistic, absent or poorly presented5 (4.4)
 OMInternal management decisions in which safety is relegated to an inferior position when there are conflicting demands or objectives5 (4.4)
 OCA collective approach to safety and risk1 (0.9)
 ORShortcomings in or the lack of roentgen photo discussions12 (10.5)
 OSShortcomings in the consultation of supervision by residents8 (7.0)
Human-related failures
 H-EXHuman failures originating beyond the control of responsibility of the investigating organisation2 (1.8)
 Knowledge based
 HKKThe inability of an individual to apply his/her existing knowledge to a novel situation29 (25.4)
 Rule based
 HRQThe incorrect fit between an individual's qualification, training or education, and a particular task16 (14.0)
 HRCA lack of task coordination within a healthcare team0(0)
 HRVThe correct and complete assessment of a situation, including related conditions of the patient and materials to be used before beginning the task6 (5.3)
 HRIFailures that result from faulty task planning and execution19 (16.7)
 HRMMonitoring of process or patient status4 (3.5)
 Skill based
 HSSFailures in the performance of highly developed skills0(0)
 HSTFailures in whole body movement0(0)
Patient-related factors
 PRFFailures related to patient characteristics or actions, which are beyond the control of the health professional team and influence treatment5 (4.4)
Other
 XFailures that cannot be classified in any of the current categories0(0)
114 (100)
  • * The description is adjusted for application on diagnosis-related closed claim files.