Table 2

Variability in SAQ dimensions within and between the US and Swiss hospital units

All 54 hospital units (n=1370)40 US units (n=1057)14 Swiss units (n=313)Differences between US and Swiss units
Safety dimensionsMean value (SD); Min.-Max. Unit %-Positive [% <60%]F; Sig*Mean value (SD); Min.-Max. Unit %- Positive [% <60%]F; SigMean value (SD); Min.-Max. Unit %-Positive [% <60%]F; SigF; Sig
Teamwork climate71.2 (13.9); 35.7–100 [20]2.66; <0.00170.9 (13.9); 35.7–100 [23]2.58; <0.00172.3 (14.4); 50–95.8 [14]3.59; <0.0010.105; 0.747
Safety climate66.0 (14.8); 29.4–90.5 [26]2.02; <0.00168.7 (13.8); 33.3–90.5 [20]1.61; <0.00158.4 (15.1); 29.4–83.3 [43]3.73; <0.0015.444; 0.024
Job satisfaction77.6 (13.2); 46.2–100 [9]2.73; <0.00179.0 (12.8); 46.2–100 [8]2.60; <0.00173.9 (13.8); 47.1–95 [14]3.53; <0.0011.536; 0.221
Stress recognition50.5 (15.8); 8.3–74.2 [67]1.02; 0.43357.2 (10.0); 28.6–74.2 [55]0.92; 0.58431.4 (13.8); 8.3–55 [100]1.29; 0.22256.920; <0.001
Perceptions of unit management55.3 (17.0); 16.7–91.7 [61]2.54; <0.00160.1 (16.4); 16.7–91.7 [48]2.97; <0.00141.5 (9.5); 28–57.1 [100]0.91; 0.54115.863; <0.001
Working conditions62.0 (15.3); 21.4–100 [43]1.24; 0.14360.7 (16.1); 21.4–100 [45]0.92; 0.58966.0 (12.6); 44.1–83.3 [36]2.73; 0.0021.269; 0.265
  • Score values of safety attitudes dimensions, range of % positive respondents and [% positive respondents below 60% thresholds].

  • * ANOVA for each safety dimension controlled for country and hospital level with significance testing for unit variability.

  • ANOVA for each safety dimension controlled for hospital level with significance testing for unit variability.

  • General linear models for between-the-country differences of safety dimensions score values at the unit level.