Effective supervisory behaviour and safety at the building site

doi:10.1016/0169-8141(94)90075-2

International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics

Volume 13, Issue 2, April 1994, Pages 85-93

https://doi.org/10.1016/0169-8141(94)90075-2 Get rights and content

Abstract

There is a need to study the connections between good management in general and safety. The study was conducted at 16 sites of a construction company. These sites had 15 site managers and 16 other first-line foremen. The accidents were analyzed according to the company accident reports. A safety checklist was developed to determine the safety level of the sites. The safety climate was measured by means of a questionnaire made up of questions concerning safety attitudes and opinions. The Operant Supervisory Taxonomy and Index (OSTI) was used in this study to analyze the supervisory behaviour. The study proved that the most effective foremen paid more attention to monitoring worker performance and spent less time indicating antecedents than did their less effective counterparts. The most effective foremen gave workers feedback about the consequences more often. The results also show that the most effective foremen spent a greater proportion of their time communicating with workers about non-work related topics. The characteristics of effective safety supervision are the same as the characteristics for generally effective supervision.

References (42)

N. Dedobbeleer et al.
A safety climate measure for construction sites
Journal of Safety Research
(1991)
D.J. Fellner et al.
Increasing industrial safety practices and conditions through posted feedback
Journal of Safety Research
(1984)
M.G. Helander
Safety hazards and motivation for safe work in the construction industry
International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics
(1991)
M. Mattila et al.
Promoting job safety in building: An experiment on the behavior analysis approach
Journal of Occupational Accidents
(1988)
M. Näsänen et al.
The effects of positive feedback on housekeeping and accidents at a shipyard
Journal of Occupational Accidents
(1987)
J. Saari et al.
The effect of positive feedback on industrial housekeeping and accidents; A long term study at a shipyard
International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics
(1989)
B. Sulzer-Azaroff
The modification of occupational safety behavior
Journal of Occupational Accidents
(1987)
L.R. Decker
A hierarchy of safety and health program elements
Professional Safety
(1984)
N. Dedobbeleer et al.
Safety practices in construction industry
Professional Safety
(1989)
D.K. Denton
Safety Management. Improving Performance

R.F. Diekemper et al.

A quantitative and qualitative measurement of industrial safety activities

ASSE Journal

(1970)

T. Ferry

Safety and Health Management Planning

D.K. Griffiths

Safety attitudes of management

Ergonomics

(1985)

R.S. Haynes et al.

Reducing accident rates with organizational behavior modification

Academic Management Journal

(1982)

H. Heinrich et al.

Industrial Accident Prevention

M. Helander

Human Factors/Ergonomics for Building and Constructions

M. Hyttinen

Rakennustyönjohtajan toiminta - psykologinen ja työsuojelullinen tarkastelu

Industrial Accidents 1988

W.G. Johnson

Safety Assurance Systems

J.L. Komaki

Promoting job safety and accident prevention

J. Komaki

Toward effective supervision: An operant analysis and comparison of managers at work

Journal of Applied Psychology

(1986)

Cited by (88)

Influential factors associated with construction managers’ propensity to implement safety measures for older workers
2021, Safety Science
Construction managers play critical roles in facilitating the retention and safety of an ageing workforce. This study aims to examine the factors underlying the high behavioural intention of construction managers to implement safety measures for their older workers. A vignette study was conducted amongst 161 construction managers in Hong Kong. The factors examined covered the dimensions of the characteristics of older construction workers, types of safety measures, and the perceptions and demographics of construction managers. The results revealed that participants most frequently (46%) treat those aged 60 years and over as older construction workers. The perceptions in awareness of workforce ageing (p < 0.01), age norms (p < 0.01), and attitude towards older workers (p < 0.01) of the participants play critical roles in influencing their likelihood of possessing high behavioural intention to implement safety measures. Participants who work in small (OR = 1.659, p < 0.05) or very large companies (OR = 1.965, p < 0.01) or have limited work experience (the OR of work experience is 0.981, p < 0.05) tend to have high behavioural intention of implementing safety measures. In addition, the participants are less likely to implement safety measures for semi-skilled workers (OR = 0.793, p < 0.05) but more likely for those who have a history of accidents (OR = 1.319, p < 0.05). The findings of this study provide a conceptual framework associated with the influential factors that predict the motivation of construction management in enhancing the occupational safety of older workers.
Safety Culture: A Retrospective Analysis of Occupational Health and Safety Mining Reports
2021, Safety and Health at Work
In the mining industry, various methods of accident analysis have utilized official accident investigations to try and establish broader causation mechanisms. An emerging area of interest is identifying the extent to which cultural influences, such as safety culture, are acting as drivers in the reoccurrence of accidents. Thus, the overall objective of this study was to analyze occupational health and safety (OHS) reports in mining to investigate if/how safety culture has historically been framed in the mining industry, as it relates to accident causation.
Using a computer-assisted qualitative data analysis software, 34 definitions of safety culture were analyzed to highlight key terms. Based on word count and contextual relevance, 26 key terms were captured. Ten OHS reports were then analyzed via an inductive thematic analysis, using the key terms. This analysis provided a concept map representing the 50-year data set and facilitated the use of text framing to highlight safety culture in the selected OHS mining reports.
Overall, 954 references and six themes, safety culture, attitude, competence, belief, patterns, and norms, were identified in the data set. Of the 26 key terms originally identified, 24 of them were captured within the text. The results made evident two distinct frames in which to interpret the data: the role of the individual and the role of the organization, in safety culture.
Unless efforts are made to understand and alter cultural drivers and share these findings within and across industries, the same accidents are likely to continue to occur.
How can communication networks among excavator crew members in construction projects affect the relationship between safety climate and safety outcomes?
2020, Safety Science
Citation Excerpt :
Open and frequent SafCom among workers and supervisors has been highli as a distinguishing feature of organizations with high SafOut, i.e., low incident rates (Alsamadani et al., 2013a, 2013b). Some researchers posit that the most successful supervisors are those who are willing to launch open discussions about safety issues among workers with different professions and to advise on safety issues when needed (Mattila et al., 1994; Niskanen, 1994; Simard and Marchand, 1994; Smith et al., 1978). Therefore, the impact of high-quality and frequent SafCom on improving the safety of a project is undeniable.
Recent research has confirmed the crucial role of safety communication in improving safety outcomes in construction sites. Safety climate is another critical factor affecting safety results; however, the interaction between safety climate and safety communication in explaining safety outcomes has remained unexplored. Assuming safety communication as an independent construct may provide opportunities to gain a better understanding of the impact of different communication modes and patterns on transforming a positive safety climate into improved safety outcomes. To address this issue, the present study investigates the intermediary role of safety communication in the relationship between safety climate and safety outcomes. The results of our analysis of communication networks among 36 excavator crews based on 259 valid questionnaires confirm that the relationship between safety climate and safety outcomes is fully mediated by safety communication. The findings of this study have theoretical and practical implications for construction safety researchers and practitioners.
Development of a frontline H&S leadership maturity model in the construction industry
2019, Safety Science
Construction frontline leaders have a crucial role in ensuring safe and healthy work practices occur where risks of accidents are highest. To create a framework for understanding and monitoring where improvements can be made, a frontline health and safety (H&S) leadership maturity model was developed. The research methods involved conducting over 100 h of participant observation at four construction sites, followed by conducting four one-hour focus groups at these sites, which were all in Australia. Six key areas in which frontline leadership behaviour can have a H&S impact emerged from the data: the foreman and subcontractor supervisor relationship; the leadership styles of the foreman and supervisor; the foreman and workers relationship; the subcontractor supervisor-to-supervisor relationship; the workgroup communication; and the relationship between the frontline leaders and H&S advisors. The three-stage model is the first known construction frontline H&S leadership maturity model, which can be used as a practical tool for industry, as well as providing theoretical insights into the ways in which frontline leaders’ influence H&S performance at the ‘sharp end’ of operations within construction projects.
Building information modeling and safety management: A systematic review
2018, Safety Science
Occupational Health and Safety (OHS) in building construction remains a worldwide problem in terms of workplace injury, illness and fatality statistics. Construction Safety requires care and planning throughout the project life-cycle, from the design phase to maintenance. Initial attempts to improve OHS consider the safety aspects in the design phase and the development of manual safety processes in the execution phase. The application of Building Information Modeling (BIM) is currently experiencing rapid growth in construction operations, planning and management, as well as in Safety Management. Thanks to the use of this new tool, we can expect to see a change in the way that safety is addressed, as seen in the literature review, based on the large number of contributions in recent years.
This study reviews the existing literature surrounding BIM and Construction Safety in order to explore both useful findings and the gaps in knowledge for future research. The main result shows that the growing implementation of BIM in the Architecture, Engineering and Construction (AEC) industry is changing the way safety can be approached. Potential safety hazards can be automatically identified and corresponding prevention methods can be applied using an automated approach.
Violation causes from the perspectives of managers and workers in Chinese railway systems: An exploratory study
2017, Safety Science
The objective of this study was to understand violation causes by Chinese railway workers, and how safety culture and personal cultural values influence their violations. We conducted a survey to investigate violation causes, perceived violation risk, violation frequency, and personal cultural values of Chinese railway workers and the safety culture of the Chinese railway system. The survey was completed by 150 railway employees (including workers and managers), from two province capital railway stations. We found that managers mainly attribute workers’ violations to saving time and energy and increasing ease, whereas they do not realize the incorrectness, impracticality, and risk of safety rules and the influence of adverse conditions and strict supervision on violations. In addition, managers perceived lower risk on all types of violations than railway workers did, especially on exceptional and optimizing violations. They believed that approaches to decreasing optimizing violations primarily involved enhancing enforcement and strengthening supervision. However, these approaches tend to be unreasonable choices for workers. From the perspective of personal cultural values, workers who rate highly in uncertainty avoidance tend to commit more routine violations, situational violations, and optimizing violations than their counterparts. Workers who rate highly in shared emotions tend to commit more routine violations than their counterparts do. No significant correlations were found between violation frequency and perceived risk by Chinese railway workers.

View all citing articles on Scopus

View full text

Effective supervisory behaviour and safety at the building site

Abstract

Journal of Safety Research

Journal of Safety Research

International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics

Journal of Occupational Accidents

Journal of Occupational Accidents

International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics

Journal of Occupational Accidents

A hierarchy of safety and health program elements

Professional Safety

Safety practices in construction industry

Professional Safety

Safety Management. Improving Performance

A quantitative and qualitative measurement of industrial safety activities

ASSE Journal

Safety and Health Management Planning

Safety attitudes of management

Ergonomics

Reducing accident rates with organizational behavior modification

Academic Management Journal

Industrial Accident Prevention

Human Factors/Ergonomics for Building and Constructions

Rakennustyönjohtajan toiminta - psykologinen ja työsuojelullinen tarkastelu

Industrial Accidents 1988

Safety Assurance Systems

Promoting job safety and accident prevention

Toward effective supervision: An operant analysis and comparison of managers at work

Journal of Applied Psychology