Original contribution
Psychiatric screening in the emergency department: Its effect on physician behavior

https://doi.org/10.1016/S0196-0644(89)80217-3Get rights and content

The purpose of our prospective, controlled study was to determine whether providing the results of a psychiatric screening instrument, the General Health Questionnaire (GHQ), to emergency physicians would result in a change in the detection and management of patients with psychosocial problems. Five hundred ninety-nine emergency department patients were enrolled, 242 in the control and 357 in the intervention group. Noncritical patients, selected by presenting complaint, were given the GHQ to complete before physician evaluation; those whose GHQ scores were high (10 or higher) were identified as having a greater likelihood of having psychosocial problems. During the intervention phase, physicians were provided the patient's GHQ score before beginning their evaluation, as well as a specific mechanism for psychosocial referral. A significantly greater proportion of patients with high GHQ scores in both study groups were judged by physicians to have a psychiatric problem (P < .0001). During the intervention phase, patients with high scores more frequently were assigned a psychiatric diagnosis (14.1% vs 7.7%) and received psychosocial referral (36.1% vs 5.7%). However, only the latter difference was statistically significant (P < .0001). The majority (85.7%) of patients offered psychosocial referral accepted their referral. There was no difference in the number of laboratory tests ordered or medical/surgical referrals requested between patients in the control or intervention groups with high scores. Therefore, providing GHQ results to emergency physicians led to more frequent psychiatric diagnoses and psychosocial referrals of patients with high GHQ scores but did not alter their medical management.

References (22)

  • NielsenAC et al.

    Depression in ambulatory medical patients

    Arch Gen Psychiatr

    (1980)
  • Cited by (26)

    • Safety and compliance with an emergency medical service direct psychiatric center transport protocol

      2008, American Journal of Emergency Medicine
      Citation Excerpt :

      Recent data suggest that the decision is clearer and may be more appropriately applied to the subgroup of psychiatric patients in whom the alternate destination is a psychiatric facility [3,8,9]. Emergency department physicians routinely perform extensive “medical clearance” evaluations for all patients who present to the ED with psychiatric signs and symptoms before referral for psychiatric evaluation or transfer to a psychiatric care facility [10-17,18]. Recently, these practices have been criticized as burdensome and often unnecessary.

    • Enabling the diagnosis of occult psychiatric illness in the emergency department: A randomized, controlled trial of the computerized, self-administered PRIME-MD diagnostic system

      2001, Annals of Emergency Medicine
      Citation Excerpt :

      The sheet was paper-clipped in front of the section of the chart where the physician writes the history and physical examination notes. We did this to replicate Gold and Baraff’s10 successful intervention in our ED. Nevertheless, it is possible that the physicians, who are used to sorting through a variety of other papers (eg, demographic information, nursing notes) to find the one they need, may have ripped off the PRIME-MD sheet without reading it.

    • Development of a Brief Mental Health Screen for Intimate Partner Violence Victims in the Emergency Department

      2007, Academic Emergency Medicine
      Citation Excerpt :

      Several obstacles also exist to screening for mental health issues in the ED. These include the fact that emergency physicians are not trained to conduct psychiatric interviews,33 the busy and chaotic environment of the ED, and the lack of interest on the part of the physician. Despite the barriers to screening in the ED, previous research has shown that screening in the ED is not only possible but also beneficial for patients.

    View all citing articles on Scopus

    Supported by a grant from the National Institute of Mental Health (RO 1 MH 3703).

    View full text